January 27

Is It Better To Replace Or Refinish A Bathtub?


Should you replace or refinish your bathtub? You’ve no doubt pondered this question if you’re tackling a home renovation. This article presents a detailed analysis about the pros and cons of both options. The insights shared in this piece come from years of expert experience in the field of bathtub resurfacing, providing you with the necessary knowledge to make an informed decision for beautifying and enhancing your bathroom space.

Table of Contents

Understanding Bathtub Refinishing

Definition of bathtub refinishing

bathtub refinishing, also known as bathtub resurfacing or reglazing, is a process used to refresh the surface of a worn-out or damaged bathtub. It is an option for bringing new life into your old bathtub without necessarily breaking the bank for a new one. This method allows you to smoothly repair cracks, chips and other superficial damage on your bathtub’s surface.

The process of refinishing a bathtub

refinishing a bathtub primarily involves three steps; cleaning, repairing, and resurfacing. The first step involves a thorough cleaning of the bathtub to remove dirt, soap scum and any loose chips. Once the tub is clean and dry, the existing surface is repaired. This may include filling in chips and cracks, and sanding the surface to create a smooth canvas for the final step. The last step of the process involves applying several layers of a specialized coating to the bathtub’s surface, effectively giving it a brand-new look.

Different materials used in bathtub refinishing

Several materials can be used to effectively resurface a bathtub. An acid etch is sometimes used to ensure that the new finish will adhere securely to the old surface. A filler material is used to repair chips and cracks, while a primer is applied to prepare the surface for the topcoat. The final step in the process is the application of a topcoat, which is typically a durable urethane or epoxy paint. These materials ensure that the tub’s new surface will be smooth, glossy, and long-lasting.

See also  What Is The Difference Between Bathtub Refinishing And Reglazing?

Understanding Bathtub Replacement

Definition of bathtub replacement

Bathtub replacement refers to the process of completely removing an existing bathtub and installing a new one in its place. It is a considered choice if your current bathtub is beyond repair or if you wish to modernize and upgrade your bathroom design with a new tub style.

Process of replacing a bathtub

The process of bathtub replacement starts with the removal of the existing tub. This may involve significant work, as it’s often necessary to remove surrounding tiles and possibly alter plumbing. Once the old bathtub is out, the area must be prepared for the new tub. This often includes installing new plumbing fixtures. The new tub is then installed and all surrounding area is repaired and refinished to complete the overall look.

Types of bathtubs for replacement

Variety is no issue when it comes to choosing a bathtub to replace your old one. There are numerous types of bathtubs available, such as soaking tubs, freestanding tubs, whirlpool tubs, alcove bathtubs, drop-in tubs, and walk-in tubs. Combined with varying materials ranging from acrylic to cast iron and copper, you have a plethora of options to choose from to ensure your new bathtub aligns with your aesthetic taste and functional needs.

Cost Considerations

Comparing the cost of bathtub refinishing vs replacement

When comparing bathtub refinishing vs replacement, refinishing is often the most cost-effective option. In general, refinishing a bathtub can cost a mere fraction of the price of a full replacement. This is because a refinishing job only necessitates buying the refinishing materials rather than a whole new bathtub. Additionally, bathtub replacement also usually involves costs associated with removing and disposing of the old tub, and potentially fixing or updating the plumbing, which all adds up.

Additional cost factors in bathtub replacement

Aside from the cost of the bathtub itself, replacing a bathtub may involve additional expenses. These can include costs associated with plumbing alterations, labor for bathtub removal and installation, repair or replacement of the surrounding tiles or wall, upgrading fixtures, waste disposal, and possibly bathroom downtime.

Additional cost factors in bathtub refinishing

While refinishing a bathtub certainly saves you cost compared to replacement, it’s not without its additional expenditure. Costs can increase depending on the condition of the tub, the type of materials used for the refinishing, and whether you choose to do it yourself or hire professionals. If the bathtub is severely worn out or damaged, more materials will be needed which will drive up the cost.

Time Factors

Duration of refinishing process

The duration of the refinishing process largely depends on the condition of your bathtub, but usually, it can be completed within a day or two. This makes it a preferable option if you want to minimize the length of time your bathroom might be unusable.

See also  How Difficult Is It To Replace A Bathtub?

Duration of replacement process

Replacing a bathtub can be quite time-consuming. Depending on the scope of the project – especially if modifications to plumbing or surrounding tiles and walls are needed – it can take anywhere from several days to a couple of weeks.

Influence of bathtub condition on timeframe

The condition of your bathtub plays a significant role in determining how long either process will take. A tub that’s in relatively good condition will take less time to refinish, but if it has serious damage, the refinishing or replacement process could take longer.

Aesthetics and Design Flexibility

Design options with bathtub refinishing

While refinishing won’t change the shape or design of your existing bathtub, it does still offer some degree of design flexibility. You can choose the colours to match your bathroom décor, you can even opt to have it done in a completely different shade if you’re looking for a change. Additionally, new coatings can often make the finish of your tub look more modern, regardless of its original design.

Design options with bathtub replacement

If you opt for bathtub replacement, the design options are considerably broader. You can choose a tub that’s larger, smaller, deeper, or with a totally different style from your current one. You also have a choice of a multitude of materials with varying textures and finishes.

Impact on overall bathroom decor

Both refinishing and replacement can significantly impact your overall bathroom decor. A refinished bathtub can bring new life to your bathroom, while a replaced bathtub can completely change the room’s layout and style. It’s essential to consider how either method aligns with your current bathroom design or proposed remodelling plan.

Durability and Lifespan

Lifespan of a refinished bathtub

With proper care and maintenance, a refinished bathtub can last for 10-15 years before needing another overhaul. Factors such as usage frequency, cleaning routines, and the quality of the refinishing product can significantly influence the lifespan of a refinished bathtub.

Lifespan of a new bathtub

A new bathtub, depending on the quality and material, can last upwards of 20 years before needing to be replaced. However, its longevity is likewise influenced by how much it’s used and how well it’s maintained.

Factors influencing durability of refinished and replaced bathtubs

Several factors influence the durability of both refinished and replaced bathtubs. These include the quality of the material used, the professionalism of the installation or refinishing process, regularity of cleaning, and method of usage. For example, using harsh or abrasive cleaning products can wear down a bathtub’s finish quicker.

Environmental Considerations

Environmental impact of bathtub refinishing

Bathtub refinishing is generally considered as the more eco-friendly option since it involves updating the current tub rather than disposing of it and buying a new one. By reusing the existing tub, you save it from ending up in a landfill, reducing your carbon footprint.

See also  When Should A Bathtub Be Replaced?

Environmental impact of bathtub replacement

Bathtub replacement, otherwise, has a higher environmental impact. It often involves sending an old tub to the landfill and manufacturing and transporting a new tub, all of which contribute to higher carbon emissions.

Sustainable options for both processes

For both bathtub refinishing and replacement, there are sustainable options available. For refinishing, it is advisable to use low-VOC products, and for new tubs, consider choosing those made from recycled or sustainable materials.

Professional Bathtub Refinishing Services

Benefits of hiring professional services for refinishing

When it comes to refinishing your bathtub, hiring professionals ensures that the job is done correctly and the finish is smooth and durable. Professional refinishers have the skills, expertise, and appropriate equipment to carry out impeccable work. They can spot potential issues with your current tub that you may miss and ensure that it’s in the best condition before applying the finish.

Process and outcome of professional refinishing

Professional bathtub refinishing starts with a thorough inspection and cleaning process, followed by the necessary repairs. Professionals know the type of materials to use for different types of tubs, and they’re proficient in applying the coatings smoothly for a seamless finish. The result is a freshly rejuvenated tub that not only costs less than a new one but also gives your bathroom a fantastic new look.

How our company can help

Our company offers expert, professional bathtub refinishing services tailored to suit your specific needs. Our team is skilled and experienced in dealing with a variety of bathtub materials and conditions. We ensure to deliver superb work within a reasonable timeframe, ensuring minimal disruption to your bathroom use.

Professional Bathtub Replacement Services

Advantages of hiring professional services for replacement

Hiring professional services for bathtub replacement ensures a hassle-free and efficient process. Professionals can help with selecting the right bathtub that suits your needs and budget. They take care of the entire replacement process, from carefully removing the old tub to installing the new one and ensuring everything is working perfectly before leaving.

Process and outcome of professional replacement

The replacement process starts with figuring out your desired outcome and choosing the right bathtub. Once that’s done, professionals carefully remove your old tub, prepare the space, and install the new one, ensuring proper plumbing connections. The outcome of professional replacement is a beautiful, functional bathtub and the assurance that the installation follows best practices for safety and longevity.

How our company can assist

Our company offers comprehensive bathtub replacement services. We aim to make the process as smooth as possible, minimizing disruption in your home. We pride ourselves on delivering high-quality workmanship and excellent customer service from the start to finish.

Making the final decision: Refinish or Replace?

Considerations to make before deciding

Deciding whether to refinish or replace your bathtub starts with evaluating the condition of your existing bathtub, determining the costs involved, and considering the time implications of each option. You should also take into account aesthetics, longevity, and any environmental considerations. Consulting with professionals can help guide you toward the best decision for your situation.

Impact on property value

Both refinishing and replacing your bathtub can have a positive impact on the value of your property, especially if you plan to sell in the future. A fresh, clean, updated bathtub can make your bathroom more appealing to potential buyers.

Personal preference vs. necessity

Ultimately, the decision to refinish or replace your bathtub could come down to personal preference versus necessity. If you love your current bathtub and want to keep it, refinishing may be the best option. But if you crave a whole new look or the current bathtub is irreparable, then replacing it may be the necessary course.

In the end, whether you decide to refinish or replace your bathtub, remember that what matters most is having a bathtub that serves its purpose in the way you want and need it to.


bathtub refinishing, DIY, Home Maintenance, Home remodeling

You may also like

Tub Reglazing in Houston 77026

Tub Reglazing in Houston 77026
{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}